Fire Island Vacation Rentals

61 rentals

PRICE PER NIGHT

ACCOMMODATION TYPES

Top-Rated Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Book a vacation rental in Fire Island that has the highest visitor rating. Here are 6 of the best vacation rentals in Fire Island.
Cozy Dix Hills Apt w/ Deck ~ 7 Mi to Beach!
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
Dishwasher · Microwave · Toiletries ·
From
$200/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Dishwasher
Microwave
Toiletries
Cable
Tv
Oven
Wifi
Air Conditioning
Other spaces
Outdoor Space, Kitchen
Ultra-Modern Studio | Near Hospital & NYCIM | WiFi
10

Excellent

·
House
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 2
·
Workspace · On Site Laundry · Kitchen ·
From
$205/night
Check availability
Property
House · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
On Site Laundry
Wifi
Storage
Furnished
In Unit Laundry
Other spaces
Workspace, Kitchen
Lovely Basement with 2 Bedrooms and Kitchen
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
Air Conditioning · Oven · Outdoor Space ·
From
$201/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Air Conditioning
Oven
Fitness Center
Furnished
In Unit Laundry
Wifi
Hot Tub
Other spaces
Outdoor Space, Kitchen, Workspace
Open bright airy basement apartment
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 1
·
Wifi · Oven · Kitchen ·
From
$69/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Wifi
Oven
Furnished
Air Conditioning
Other spaces
Kitchen, Workspace
cozy and convenient apartment 1 min from train.
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
3 br
·
Sleeps 7
·
Wifi · Air Conditioning · Furnished ·
From
$162/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 3 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Wifi
Air Conditioning
Furnished
Rodeway Inn Huntington Station - Melville
5.1

Good

·
Hotel
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
Assigned Parking · Furnished · Carpet ·
From
$63/night
Check availability
Property
Hotel · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Assigned Parking
Furnished
Carpet
Free Parking
Air Conditioning
Business Center
Wifi
Other spaces
Workspace

Our Recommended Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

We analyzed vacation rentals in Fire Island from many property providers including but not limited to VRBO, Booking.com, Evolve, Blueground and more. We're providing our top recommended offers on the best vacation rentals in Fire Island to help you find a deal for your next trip.
100 Court North Dr #1660A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
In Unit Laundry · Oven · Balcony ·
From
$166/night
Min stay: 90 nights
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
In Unit Laundry
Oven
Furnished
Air Conditioning
Microwave
Elevator
Wifi
Fireplace
Other spaces
Balcony
1700 E 5th St #1221A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Furnished · Elevator · In Unit Laundry ·
From
$166/night
Min stay: 90 nights
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 2 baths
Amenities
Furnished
Elevator
In Unit Laundry
Dishwasher
Oven
Tv
Wifi
Microwave
1700 E 5th St #1245A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Wifi · Elevator · Air Conditioning ·
From
$186/night
Min stay: 90 nights
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 2 baths
Amenities
Wifi
Elevator
Air Conditioning
Furnished
Microwave
In Unit Laundry
Tv
Oven
313 Avalon Cir #1273A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Fireplace · Balcony · Oven ·
From
$180/night
Min stay: 90 nights
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Fireplace
Oven
In Unit Laundry
Furnished
Dishwasher
Air Conditioning
Wifi
Tv
Other spaces
Balcony
313 Avalon Cir #1255A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Furnished · Tv · Wifi ·
From
$177/night
Min stay: 90 nights
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 2 baths
Amenities
Furnished
Tv
Wifi
Air Conditioning
Dishwasher
Oven
Elevator
In Unit Laundry
Other spaces
Balcony
313 Avalon Cir #1256A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Dishwasher · Oven · Balcony ·
From
$175/night
Min stay: 90 nights
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 2 baths
Amenities
Dishwasher
Oven
Air Conditioning
Tv
Wifi
Fireplace
Elevator
Furnished
Other spaces
Balcony

Budget-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Traveling on a budget? We've got you covered. Find a great deal on a vacation rental in Fire Island starting at $58. Use the price filter at the top of the page to search for more specific prices.
Legal Gorgeous Studio Apartment All inclusive

No rating

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
On Site Laundry · Carpet · Dishwasher ·
From
$58/night
Min stay: 30 nights
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
On Site Laundry
Carpet
Dishwasher
Cable
In Unit Laundry
Assigned Parking
Garage Parking
Hardwood Floor
Other spaces
Outdoor Space
Earl

No rating

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
Outdoor Space · Carpet · Cable ·
From
$60/night
Min stay: 30 nights
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Carpet
Cable
Other spaces
Outdoor Space
37 Jennings Ave ##3

No rating

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
Air Conditioning · Fireplace ·
From
$62/night
Min stay: 30 nights
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Air Conditioning
Fireplace
93 Route 109 Apt A #Apt A

No rating

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
Oven · Air Conditioning ·
From
$70/night
Min stay: 30 nights
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Oven
Air Conditioning
Expand your search criteria to see more vacation rentals.
Home > Destinations Vacation Rentals > Fire Island Vacation Rentals
Updated: March 1, 2024