Skip to navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
Vacations by Zumper

Fire Island Vacation Rentals

PRICE PER NIGHT

ACCOMMODATION TYPES

Top-Rated Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Book a vacation rental in Fire Island that has the highest visitor rating. Here are 6 of the best vacation rentals in Fire Island.
Price drop
Large renovated 5BR home w/ heated pool, hot-tub & ping-pong in Bellport Village
10

Excellent

·
House
·
4 br
·
Sleeps 8
·
Dishwasher · Residents Lounge · Air Conditioning ·
From
$627/night
Check availability
Property
House · 4 Beds · 3 baths
Amenities
Dishwasher
Residents Lounge
Air Conditioning
Furnished
Hot Tub
Garage Parking
Beach
Private Pool
Other spaces
Kitchen, Workspace
Price drop
Bayfront Fun! - 3 BR and 3 Ensuite Bath with Hot Tub!
10

Excellent

·
House
·
3 br
·
Sleeps 6
·
Wheelchair Accessible · Wifi · Furnished ·
From
$780/night
Check availability
Property
House · 3 Beds · 3 baths
Amenities
Wheelchair Accessible
Wifi
Furnished
Hot Tub
Oven
Waterfront
In Unit Laundry
Residents Lounge
Other spaces
Balcony, Kitchen
Price drop
Perfect, Central, Quiet Bellport Village Cottage—With New Heated Saltwater Pool!
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
3 br
·
Sleeps 6
·
Hot Tub · Fireplace · Furnished ·
From
$400/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 3 Beds · 2 baths
Amenities
Hot Tub
Fireplace
Furnished
In Unit Laundry
Swimming Pool
Garage Parking
Dishwasher
Private Pool
Other spaces
Kitchen
Relax or Work While Away
10

Excellent

·
House
·
3 br
·
Sleeps 6
·
Oven · Dishwasher · Wifi ·
From
$293/night
Check availability
Property
House · 3 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Oven
Dishwasher
Wifi
Fireplace
In Unit Laundry
Air Conditioning
Furnished
Other spaces
Balcony, Kitchen
PINES AMPLE 1 BED APT!-PETS OK
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
Hardwood Floor · Outdoor Space · Residents Lounge ·
From
$248/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Hardwood Floor
Residents Lounge
Fitness Center
Furnished
Oven
Dishwasher
Ceiling Fan
Beach
Other spaces
Kitchen
Price drop
Fully Renovated Family Beach House 2022 Dates now available!
10

Excellent

·
House
·
4 br
·
Sleeps 12
·
Outdoor Space · Wifi · Dishwasher ·
From
$1,200/night
Check availability
Property
House · 4 Beds · 2 baths
Amenities
Wifi
Dishwasher
In Unit Laundry
Oven
Fireplace
Residents Lounge
Furnished
Air Conditioning
Other spaces
Kitchen

Budget-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Traveling on a budget? We've got you covered. Find a great deal on a vacation rental in Fire Island starting at $63. Use the price filter at the top of the page to search for more specific prices.
Rodeway Inn Huntington Station - Melville
5.2

Good

·
Hotel
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
Assigned Parking · Furnished · Carpet ·
From
$63/night
Check availability
Property
Hotel · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Assigned Parking
Furnished
Carpet
Free Parking
Air Conditioning
Business Center
Wifi
Other spaces
Workspace
Open bright airy basement apartment
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
Studio
·
Sleeps 1
·
Wifi · Oven · Kitchen ·
From
$69/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · Studio · 1 bath
Amenities
Wifi
Oven
Furnished
Air Conditioning
Other spaces
Kitchen, Workspace
Beautiful room with bathroom on nice dead end block
10

Excellent

·
House
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 30
·
Wifi · In Unit Laundry · Furnished ·
From
$73/night
Check availability
Property
House · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Wifi
In Unit Laundry
Furnished
Air Conditioning
Cozy Nesting in quiet area
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
In Unit Laundry · Oven · Kitchen ·
From
$75/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
In Unit Laundry
Oven
Furnished
Wifi
Other spaces
Kitchen
Emerald glam room
10

Excellent

·
House
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 2
·
Furnished · Smoking Allowed · In Unit Laundry ·
From
$79/night
Check availability
Property
House · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Furnished
Smoking Allowed
In Unit Laundry
Wifi
Oven
Other spaces
Kitchen
Snow Birds, Transitions, Temporary Work Assignments, This is it!
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
1 br
·
Sleeps 2
·
Furnished · Wifi · Kitchen ·
From
$80/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 1 Bed · 1 bath
Amenities
Furnished
Wifi
Fitness Center
Air Conditioning
Oven
Dishwasher
Other spaces
Kitchen

Vacation Rentals With AC and/or Heat in Fire Island, NY

Whether you need air conditioning or central heating, these vacation rentals are for you.
Price drop
Bay Shore Vacation Rental w/ Shared Yard!
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
3 br
·
Sleeps 6
·
Workspace · Kitchen · Furnished ·
From
$287/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 3 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Furnished
On Site Laundry
Garage Parking
Air Conditioning
In Unit Laundry
Wifi
Central Heat
Dishwasher
Other spaces
Workspace, Kitchen
Cozy Dix Hills Apt w/ Deck ~ 7 Mi to Beach!
10

Excellent

·
Apartment
·
2 br
·
Sleeps 4
·
Dishwasher · Microwave · Toiletries ·
From
$145/night
Check availability
Property
Apartment · 2 Beds · 1 bath
Amenities
Dishwasher
Microwave
Toiletries
Cable
Tv
Oven
Wifi
Air Conditioning
Other spaces
Kitchen
Price drop
Long Island Getaway w/ Pool - Close to Beaches!
10

Excellent

·
House
·
4 br
·
Sleeps 12
·
Central Heat · Furnished · Oven ·
From
$529/night
Check availability
Property
House · 4 Beds · 3 baths
Amenities
Central Heat
Furnished
Oven
Private Pool
Pool
Residents Lounge
Wifi
In Unit Laundry
Other spaces
Workspace, Kitchen
Expand your search criteria to see more vacation rentals.
Home > Destinations Vacation Rentals > Fire Island Vacation Rentals
Updated: September 17, 2023